UK light heavyweight Buatsi made a winning yet disappointing start to his career under fresh promotional backing with a points victory over Zach Parker in Manchester.
The Olympic medal winner's activity level likely gained him a judges' verdict in a tight ten-round fight at the boxing arena.
But the challenger found success, delivering effective individual punches in a contest where the styles didn't complement each other, with frequent clinching disrupting the contest.
The officials scored it 96-94 for to the winner, with the third a 95-95 draw.
"It wasn't my finest showing but how do champions respond? They succeed," Buatsi stated in the arena as he was faced disapproval from the crowd.
The British fighter bounced back after his first professional defeat - an epic battle with Callum Smith in last winter - to earn a 20th pro success.
Several boxing experts felt Parker, 31, should have been awarded the victory but the contender suffered the second setback of his 28-bout professional journey.
Buatsi Earns Triumph in Dull Encounter
His career development has stalled in recent times through promotional disputes and extended periods of lack of fights.
Once tipped as the next star of UK boxing, he now finds himself trying to realize his potential - perhaps in what seems like a last chance - under fresh management.
He opened tentatively, with the two boxers willing to take risks in a calculated early stages.
The challenger, whose sole prior loss came at super-middleweight against John Ryder in two years ago after breaking his hand mid-fight, was competing in only his second fight at light-heavyweight.
By the middle rounds, the underdog had stayed in contention, making life awkward for the favorite, who operated with a solid defense to edge the cleaner stanzas.
The crowd's patience wore thin amid constant clinching, with Parker going down several times during clinches.
The underdog closed well, but several stanzas were hard to judge. However, ex-champion Carl Frampton - commentating on the broadcast network - had it significantly in favor for Parker, scoring for Buatsi just a single round.
Buatsi progresses, but with the caliber of power puncher Benavidez, and Eastern European fighter Dmitry Bivol leading the category, the path to championship success - on this evidence - still appears challenging.
Ricky Hatton Homage Inspires All-Manchester Contest
In the supporting bout, Arthur beat Rea by divided decision in a terrific local rivalry contest to capture the European light-heavyweight championship.
The stadium fell silent for a deeply poignant tribute ahead of the contest as ten bells sounded in remembrance of local hero Hatton, who passed away 46 years old in recently.
It was the premier televised boxing event in the city since Hatton's passing. As the final chime disappeared, the stillness became a roar of "there's only one Ricky Hatton".
The competition inside the ropes reflected the sentiment. The eventual winner was floored by a left hook flush on the jaw in the second round, getting up unsteadily to his feet on the referee's count.
But the traditional red equipment of the fighter soon advanced again. From the other corner, Rea - in competitive blue - was marked up soon, significant bruising forming under his eye as the pair traded hard punches.
The challenger, twenty-seven, landed power punches but Arthur, thirty-four, fought fire with fire with powerful upward punches as the action seldom decreased over 12 rounds.
The victor narrowly won the result with official scores of 114-114, close margin and wider gap, but the two athletes were relentless and brave, exactly what their hero the legend embodied.